FAQs – Applicable to All Medical Malpractice Schemes

Frequently Asked Questions

This is one of the most common questions we’re asked, and there’s no simple answer.

Medical malpractice claims can be unpredictable. Even your broker can’t guarantee that a specific limit of cover will be enough for every possible scenario. A single claim involving proven negligence that results in a patient’s permanent disability could exceed the R10 million maximum cover offered under our standard policy.

When deciding on your cover limit, think about the following:

  1. Legal costs and compensation: Your limit must cover both legal defence and any settlement or court-awarded damages.
  2. Affordability: Always aim to take the highest limit of cover you can afford. It's a balance between risk and cost.
  3. Rising claims: Both the frequency and cost of medical malpractice claims are increasing.
  4. Think like a claimant: If you were injured and unable to work again, how much would you expect in compensation? Consider your remaining working years, potential lost income (adjusted for inflation), and long-term medical expenses.
  5. Higher-risk patients: You should consider a higher limit if you treat:
    • Minors
    • High net-worth individuals
    • Sports professionals
    • Celebrities
    • Foreign nationals
  6. Ceasing practice: If you’re retiring or emigrating, take the highest limit you can afford before you stop practicing. Your run-off cover will only be offered at your last active limit.
  7. Practice owners: If you own or operate a practice, your exposure goes beyond your personal conduct. You may be held vicariously liable for the actions of your employees or contractors. In addition, you may require cover for public liability (e.g. if a patient is injured on your premises) and product liability if you supply or recommend products used in treatment. These factors increase your overall risk and should be considered when selecting your indemnity limit.
  8. Regulatory complaints: A large portion of the matters we handle are not medical malpractice claims but complaints to regulatory bodies, even in cases where no patient harm occurred. While defence costs for these matters typically don’t exceed R1 million, they still require skilled legal support and adequate insurance.

If you’d like a limit higher than R10 million, contact us.

Don’t wait - early notification is essential. If someone is making allegations or complaining - even informally, please contact us without delay.

Email: claims.cfp@garrun-group.co.za
WhatsApp: 076 284 8108

You are required to notify us as soon as you become aware of any situation that could potentially give rise to a claim or complaint, even if no formal action has been taken yet. Do not wait for a letter from a lawyer or an official notification from your regulatory body (HPCSA, AHPCSA, or SANC) before reaching out.

Unfortunately, we have seen claims rejected for late notification.

Your medical malpractice insurance policy is a claims-made policy, meaning that the timing of your notification is critical. If in doubt, report it - early notification protects your rights and allows us to support you from the outset.

Please notify us immediately as we will need to:

  1. establish how much run-off cover you may be entitled to; and
  2. place your policy on run-off cover at the appropriate time.

If you do not notify us before you stop practicing, your policy will automatically lapse, and you may lose your entitlement to cover. It’s important to maintain your medical malpractice insurance until the end of the policy period in the year you cease practicing. Even if you work just one day during that year, your cover should remain active until the policy period concludes.

Retroactive cover protects you against claims made now for work you did before your current policy started. Without it, past incidents may not be covered.

Medical malpractice insurance is issued on a claims-made basis, which means the policy that responds to a claim is the one active at the time you report the incident, not the one you had when the treatment was provided.

To ensure you’re properly protected, you must have:

  1. Cover in place when the treatment or professional service was rendered;
  2. Cover in place when you first become aware of a potential claim or complaint and notify it to us in writing; and
  3. Continuous cover between these two points, with no gaps in insurance.

Your retro-active date is the date from which your insurer agrees to cover incidents from the past. If there’s a break in cover, even for a day, you could lose that retro-active protection, and claims relating to past services may be declined.

If you don’t renew your policy (or place it into run-off when you retire or stop practicing), any new claim reported after the policy has lapsed won’t be covered, even if the work was done while the policy was active.

The only exception is if you notified a potential claim in writing while the policy was still in force, and that notification was accepted and registered by your insurer.

It a condition of your Medical Malpractice Insurance policy that you obtain written informed consent from your patient before providing any treatment, product or procedure. Without it, insurers may reject your claim and decline support.

Your insurance policy requires insurers to defend you against negligence claims. But without written evidence of informed consent from your patients, your ability to defend yourself is severely weakened.

Informed consent is not only crucial for your insurance coverage but also a mandatory requirement under regulatory body guidelines. The HPCSA (Health Professions Council of South Africa) requires healthcare practitioners to obtain informed consent from patients. This ensures patients understand the nature, risks, benefits, and alternatives related to their care. Informed consent isn’t just a one-time administrative step; it’s an ongoing process throughout treatment. If the risks of treatment change significantly, you must update and re-obtain consent accordingly.

Claims can be made years after treatment, so keeping detailed records and signed consent forms is your best chance to defend yourself effectively. Remember, the law focuses on proof, not just the truth, so thorough notes and documented consent in your records are essential.

About the Policy

Medical malpractice indemnity
Covers claims made against you for injury, harm, or death suffered by a patient arising from your alleged negligence in the rendering of healthcare-related services. This includes failure to diagnose, misdiagnosis, or delayed diagnosis. The policy is triggered by an allegation that your action or omission caused the patient’s loss or harm.

Professional indemnity insurance 
Covers claims made against you for financial loss suffered by a third party arising from your alleged negligence or errors in the rendering of professional services, which has caused a financial loss to a Third Party.

Defence Costs
Covers the legal costs incurred in defending claims or allegations made against you, even if the claim is ultimately unfounded. This includes attorney fees, expert reports, and related legal expenses, provided the claim falls within the scope of your policy.

Public Liability Insurance (Optional) 
Covers your legal liability to members of the public for injury or property damage caused by negligence in connection with your business or professional premises.
For example, a client falls down the stairs due to a loose handrail you were aware of and sues for medical expenses. Or perhaps a client’s car is damaged when a gate on your premises closes on it, and they allege it was due to inadequate safety measures.

Product Liability Insurance including defective workmanship (Optional) 
Covers claims alleging injury or property damage caused by a product you sold or supplied, including issues with packaging or labelling. For example, if a product you provide is alleged to be defective and causes harm, this cover would respond.

General Extensions

  • Breach Of Confidentiality

  • Court/Inquiry Attendance Costs

  • Cross Liabilities

  • Defamation

  • Employers Liability (If Stated In The Schedule To Apply)

  • Indemnity To Others

  • Medical Scheme Investigation / Audits

  • Public Relations Expenses

  • Regulatory Or Statutory Body Defence Costs

  • Statutory Defence Costs

  • Wrongful Arrest

Special Extensions

  • Extended Reporting Period

  • Extended Territorial Coverage For Short-Term Services

  • Liability Following Employee/Volunteer Dishonesty

  • Run Off Cover (Up to 6 years’ included at no additional cost)

The policy document will be provided to you. It is your responsibility to ensure that you read and understand all the policy terms, conditions and exclusions and if you do not that you contact us, in writing, for clarification/explanations. We urge you to read the policy documents and to contact us if you have any questions.

Email: info@cover4profs.co.za

Cover is limited to 60 consecutive days for temporary visits world-wide, excluding the United States of America, Canada and Australia.

The policy does not cover you if you emigrate overseas, but rather provides cover for those visiting overseas temporarily and rendering services which fall within your scope of practice as described on your policy schedule.

If you render services overseas from time to time, we recommend that you take the R10 million limit of indemnity, as the lower limits could leave you underinsured.  You need to consider maintaining your cover at the higher limit not only when you render the services but for some years thereafter until the any potential claimants claim prescribes.
Your policy limit is provided on an aggregate basis, meaning one total limit applies to all claims made during the policy period. This limit includes all legal defence costs, settlement amounts, damages, VAT, and interest, each of which reduces the remaining balance of your cover for the rest of the insurance period.

You cannot increase your limit of indemnity once a claim has been made or notified. If you apply for a higher limit after a claim, the increased limit will only apply to future, unrelated claims. Any existing or known matters will remain subject to the original limit in place at the time they were reported.

The policy offers options for cover of up to R10 million. If you would like to explore higher limits, please contact us to discuss available options.

The limit of indemnity is inclusive of VAT. If you are a VAT vendor, you need to ensure that the limit of indemnity chosen can cover your VAT liability in the event of a claim.
You will need to pay an excess if Insurers have had to incur legal costs and expenses in the investigation and defence of a claim against you, regardless of whether you successfully defend the claim or not.

Additional deductibles may be applicable should you have more than one claim in a policy period, or for certain specific procedures. These are clearly outlined in your policy document.

Please note that in the list below we are providing information in respect of some of the exclusions of cover.  We urge you to carefully read the policy schedule and policy wording document which provides full details of all of the exclusions of cover.

The policy will NOT cover:

  • claims/complaints arising out of services rendered which fall outside your scope of practice, unless such services fall under the Good Samaritan clause where you rendered services at the scene of an emergency.

  • claims/complaints arising out of services rendered prior to your retroactive cover date.

  • claims/complaints which have not been timeously reported

  • fines, penalties, punitive, vindictive or exemplary damages imposed on you or awarded against you.

  • any amounts you pay to that patient or that you agree to pay in a medical aid audit.

  • allegations of sexual misconduct in the course and scope of your practice. However, if you are subsequently found not guilty or liable, then the policy will refund you your defence costs. For this reason, you should notify us of any allegations against you or your employee of sexual misconduct.

  • claims/complaints arising out of services rendered when you were under the influence of drugs or alcohol.

  • claims/complaints which you were aware of in a previous policy period but failed to notify us of at the time.

  • claims for cyber-liability, employment practices’ liability, directors’ and officers’ liability and commercial crime.

  • losses that you suffer as the result of your own employees stealing from you.

  • claims/complaints arising out of any dishonest, criminal or malicious act or omission, or any act or omission in violation of any law or ordinance, committed by or on behalf of your practice, save where such criminal or illegal conduct is negligent and not reckless or intentional.

  • claims/complaints arising out of any loss, damage, cost or expense directly or indirectly arising out of, contributed to by, or resulting from any infectious epidemic/pandemic.

The policy document will be provided to you. It is your responsibility to ensure that you read and understand all the policy terms, conditions and exclusions and if you do not that you contact us, in writing, for clarification/explanations. We urge you to read the policy documents and to contact us if you have any questions.

Email: info@cover4profs.co.za

Designed to cover the resultant costs and damages from a privacy breach or a network security breach, a cyber insurance policy covers what has previously been uninsurable providing comprehensive first and third-party coverages with an expert incident response process.

Far broader than the name cyber would imply, our policy extends to cover numerous incidents including but not limited to:

  • Physical data theft and loss (both devices and physical hard copy data).

  • Cyber extortion and malware (viruses, ransomware, or publishing of stolen data).

  • Denial of service (disruption to operations).

  • Downstream attack (a compromise of your environment resulting in damages to others).

  • Hacking.

  • Insider and privilege misuse (unauthorised access and use of systems and data by employees and service providers).

  • Threats posed by third-party access into a client environment.

While Cyber Liability Insurance does NOT replace good IT security practices, a cyber liability policy does provide a safety net to protect you, your business and your patients.  We have negotiated discounted rates and there are two types of cyber covers to offer exclusively to our scheme policyholders.

Click here to find a table comparing the products available

Commonly Used Insurance Terms

A claims-made policy provides cover for claims that are made against you during the period your policy is active, provided the event or incident that gave rise to the claim happened after the policy's retroactive date.

This means:
• You must have active cover at the time the claim is made, even if the incident happened earlier.
• The incident must have occurred on or after your retroactive date (a date that’s usually set when you first take out the policy and maintained as long as you keep renewing without a break in cover).

One of the key features of a claims-made policy is that it is essential to notify your insurer of any claim or potential claim (also known as circumstances) as soon as you become aware of it, and while your policy is still active. This is because once you notify the matter, it is considered “made” for the purposes of the policy.
Provided the incident falls within the scope of cover and all the policy terms and conditions are met, the insurer will respond to the claim, even if the actual legal process continues after your policy has expired.

Why is this important?
If your policy lapses or is cancelled before you notify a claim or potential issue, you may not have any cover, even if the incident happened while you were insured. Timely notification is critical to ensure your protection under a claims-made policy.

An excess is the amount you are required to contribute toward any claim made under your policy.

You will be required to pay an excess, which is clearly reflected on your policy schedule, once the insurer incurs legal costs and expenses in investigating or defending a claim made against you. This applies even in cases where the matter is resolved in your favour, or not.

The excess is your portion of shared responsibility in managing the risk, and it helps ensure that claims are handled promptly and thoroughly. Your insurer will support and guide you throughout the process, but this contribution is a standard feature of most insurance policies.

It is a condition of the policy, that in the event that a complaint/claim/incident report is received by you/your practice, regardless of who it is from, it must be submitted immediately to us in writing.

Do not wait for formal legal action to be taken against you or to receive an official notification from your regulatory body that a complaint has been lodged against you before you notify your insurers of a claim.

If you choose to respond without guidance/consultation, the Insurer’s rights are reserved.

Email: claims.cfp@garrun-group.co.za

WhatsApp: 076 284 8108

Retroactive cover refers to the protection a claims-made policy provides for incidents that occurred before the current policy period, but after the retroactive date stated on your policy schedule.

Key Points to Understand:

  • The retroactive date is the date you first took out a claims-made insurance policy.

  • You will not be covered for any claim arising from services rendered before this retroactive date.

  • This date appears clearly on your policy schedule, which your insurer will provide each year.

Why Is Continuous Cover So Important?

In order to maintain your retroactive cover, you must renew your policy on time every year and ensure there are no breaks or gaps in your cover.
If your cover lapses or is not renewed promptly, you may
forfeit your retroactive cover, meaning you will lose protection for past work.

Proving Your Retroactive Cover

It is essential to keep records that show you have maintained continuous insurance, as insurers may require proof of your entitlement to retroactive cover.

Keep the following documents in a safe and easily accessible place, ideally indefinitely:

  1. Policy schedules (from all previous years)

  2. Proof of insurance letters

  3. Proof of payment

Purchasing Retroactive Cover on a New Policy

If you are taking out a new policy (not a renewal), insurers may offer you the option to purchase retroactive cover, often up to 3 years back. However, this will not cover any known or pre-existing issues you were already aware of before the policy started.

This is why it's important to declare any known incidents or complaints when applying for cover.

Run-off cover, sometimes referred to as an Additional Reporting Period, is an extension of your liability insurance policy that allows you to continue reporting claims or potential claims even after you have stopped practicing and are no longer paying for active cover.

What Does It Cover?

  • Run-off cover does not cover ongoing work or new activities.

  • It only provides protection for claims or complaints that arise from services you rendered while your policy was active and fully paid.

  • This is especially relevant for professionals who are retiring, ceasing to practice, or closing their business.

Why Is It Important?

When a claims-made policy lapses (i.e. is not renewed or cancelled), you can no longer report or claim for any incidents, even if the service in question was provided while your policy was active. This could leave you personally liable for claims made after you stop working, a risk that can extend for years.

Run-off cover is therefore crucial to protect yourself, your estate, and your family from future claims, especially in the event of your retirement, incapacity, or even death. We have seen instances where claims were brought against a practitioner’s estate long after they passed away.

Run-off cover is not automatic, we will need to activate the run off based on your entitlement.

  • Always review your policy and contact us before allowing your policy to lapse or choosing not to renew it.

  • If you are planning to cease practice, close your business, or retire, we strongly recommend arranging appropriate run-off cover in advance.

Your legal liability to someone doesn’t last forever. In South African law, a person must bring a claim against you within a reasonable time, or they lose the right to do so, this is called prescription.

Most claims prescribe after 3 years from the date the person becomes aware (or should reasonably have become aware) of the loss and who caused it. After that, they can no longer legally enforce the claim against you.

However, there are exceptions, such as claims involving minors (which can extend up to 19 years), or claims interrupted by acknowledgment of debt or legal action.

Always seek legal advice if you're unsure, these time limits can have serious consequences.

If someone makes a claim against you after the prescription period has lapsed, and you pay them anyway (either out of fear, confusion, or to avoid a dispute), the law sees that as you choosing to pay a debt voluntarily, even though legally, the debt no longer exists. Once you’ve paid, you’ve essentially waived your right to raise the prescription defence.

Compliance Documents

2025 Garrun CFP & iTOO Disclosure document

Representative Introductions and Section 13 Mandates

© Copyright 2025. All Rights Reserved. Designed & Developed by ThinkTank Creative